Wednesday, July 21, 2010

A great speech on sprawl

http://www.ted.com/talks/james_howard_kunstler_dissects_suburbia.html

Tuesday, July 20, 2010

The Railroad Park - A Future Success!

Comfort and Image



These recycling bins give the park a good image. They make a good first impression both aesthetically and environmentally. I already feel that this park will have a certain level of class, just based on the presence of these tastefully done recycling bins.

Uses and Activities


This is a distant photo of the playground. Nearby will be the skaters' area. The playground gives parents with their young children something to do, the skate park will give the teenagers something to do, and the benches surrounding the two will give everyone else something to do -- people watch.




This is another play area for children, which can also be fun for teenagers, and heck, even adults. It also serves as a group activity space, with its long semi-circle of benches for people to sit on and listen to a speaker.

Sociability



With such a beautiful, unique view as this, I would be compelled to bring my friends here. I can easily imagine this park becoming the tourist attraction in Birmingham; where everyone brings their relatives and out-of-town friends to hang out while showing off Birmingham. With the added feature of beer and food, as in the photo below, nothing else stands a chance.

Wednesday, July 14, 2010

6.4 Open-Space Types




"Provide a range of familiar types of public space"

The top picture is a park that is both for the neighborhood as well as the school. It is within walking distance to both, and serves a variety of functions.

The second picture is a park within the neighborhood that is a 2 minute walk from several houses, and also easily accessible by the whole neighborhood.

They both provide common spaces for people to meet one another, bump into their neighbors, or meet their neighbors' friends. This boosts social capital and again, I can see no deficit to providing these parks.

8.5 On-Street Parking



The on-street parking you see here slows down drivers, protects pedestrians from traffic, diminishes the need for parking lots, and increases activity on the sidewalk because drivers get out of their cars and enter the sidewalk. Mt. Laurel follows the manual here in that parallel parking is standard.

10.2 Short Setbacks



The community church does not have a giant parking lot from the sidewalk to the building. It's entrance is close to the street, easily accessible to pedestrians. The manual adds that having a short setback increases the "sense of enclosure". This is what makes Mt. Laurel quaint. It discourages driving and makes allows pedestrians to feel comfortable in the smaller space, as well as not making them walk so far to reach their destination.

9.5 Pavement Materials



This sidewalk is made to be permeable, allowing the rainwater to filter through. It is a more environmentally-friendly sidewalk and helps prevent flooding. The porosity also helps the trees nearby get the water they need. Not only does this sidewalk provide all that, but it is pretty! It adds interest to the sidewalks, again encouraging pedestrians.

9.1 Sidewalks



Not only does Mt. Laurel have sidewalks all throughout, but also bike paths as shown here. For the houses situated farther from center, bikes are more convenient. These designated bike paths should encourage these residents to bike, but it still seems that a lot of them have golf carts as use those instead. This is probably a compromise on the residents' part, who are accustomed to driving everywhere and haven't gotten used to this new idea of exercising in order to complete an errand. Hopefully it encourages the younger residents to become accustomed to this "new" idea, and will insist on that type of neighborhood more in the future.

8.13 Passages and Paths



Each one of Mt. Laurel's many footpaths is distinguished by this unique stone triangle. The paths encourage walking by making it beautiful, organic and separated from traffic. This benefits the community by making it less dependent on cars, making walking and jogging more enjoyable so the residents are healthier, and providing shortcuts when making quick stops to the neighborhood center. I see no deficit whatsoever in providing these pleasant trails. Mt. Laurel did a wonderful job creating so many of these paths.

5.12 Clustering Houses



Down this alley is a multitude of small houses closely spaced together. The laws forced Mt. Laurel to be creative in its methods to have these houses situated so closely, and they did a wonderful job. I do wonder, though, what a fire truck would have to do if one of these houses *did* catch fire...but I'm sure they thought of that, too. Part of the intent is to offer more affordable, smaller housing, and the other reason for doing this is to increase density as well as preserve the natural environment. The benefit of this principle is the retained green space, and the density that makes the walk to the grocery store that much shorter for all the residents. The deficit for some people would be decreased privacy. I don't think it really affects people's privacy that much, but when talking to my parents, they both scoffed at the idea of not having the space of a large backyard to "buffer" their outdoor privacy.

5.11 Nearby Farms



This is the food for sale very close to Mt. Laurel's neighborhood. It is organically grown on a farm just down the street from the residents. This farm provides the community food security, one of the smart growth principles. I think it relates to people's behavior in that they will be more likely to eat fresh, locally grown produce rather than fast food because it is so close to home. The obvious benefit here is better health. The farm also benefits from their organic produce being readily available to locals that might otherwise suffer competition from cheaper alternatives.
This design did a great job achieving its goal for the neighborhood's food security.

The Neighborhood - 1.6 Growth Properties




I'm tempted to criticize this aspect of Mt. Laurel. According to the Smart Growth Manual, this is low on the scale of smart-to-dumb development. When looking at a Google map image of Birmingham and where Mt. Laurel is situated (http://maps.google.com/maps?hl=en&q=mt.%20laurel,%20birmingham&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=il), it rates a 6 out of 8 -- "New neighborhoods on existing intrastructure". There is no urban revitalization taking place here. Mt. Laurel is far, far away from the city with no means of public transportation. They pride themselves in not being a gated community, yet its distant location might as well be a gate, not to mention that the lake actually does have a locked gate. The benefit here is a greater sense of community amongst the people living here. The deficit is friends of these members making the long trip out here, much less strangers coming in to shop, eat, or enjoy the parks. This limits the neighbors' social capital.
Perhaps Mt. Laurel is planning in "increments of complete neighborhoods", but that requires quite a lot of neighborhoods before they reach the center of Birmingham.

My thoughts on Mt. Laurel

I found Mt. Laurel to be quaint and beautiful. A great idea for what suburbs should be. I still think of it as a suburb because it is so far away from the city of Birmingham. If I wanted to live outside the city, Mt. Laurel would definitely be my choice. The multitude of trees, the ten minute walk to the center, a lake, porches along the sidewalks -- all that is fabulous. I think it will be very successful for all the rich families that have the choice between a regular suburb and this gorgeous, convenient one.
I don't fantasize about one day being rich and moving to Mt. Laurel. If I wanted to leave Mt. Laurel to go anywhere else in Birmingham, I would be stuck on the far end of 280. I'm also skeptical about the variety of jobs available within Mt. Laurel. As a future occupational therapist, I wonder if there would be potential for a therapy clinic, and if the business could survive off Mt. Laurel residents and the neighboring suburb, and if outsiders would travel all that way on 280.
The design of the community certainly gives the neighborhood a calmer feeling. The trees, the porches, and the pedestrian accessibility all lessen the sense of sterility and rushing to get things done feeling I normally have in suburbs and non-walkable locations. Whenever I'm in my car, or in an environment that wants me to be in my car, I feel I have to finish my task so I can escape my car as soon as possible. Mt. Laurel did not give me that sense of urgency. I like that.

Saturday, July 10, 2010

Documenting Sprawl 3

This is a section of Highway 31 in Hoover. There is at least 6 lanes for traffic here, possibly a 7th for a turn lane on the opposite side, like there is on this side. This is the street everyone must travel in order to shop, eat, and get to work if they live in Hoover. I do not recommend trying to walk from your manicurist on one side of the street to your favorite restaurant on the other side of the street. In fact, not only do I not recommend it, but it's probably illegal. And you'll probably die.

Yesterday I was making a right-hand turn onto 31, and noticed a pedestrian waiting to cross the street. There are no cross-walks on 31. Period. I threw all my junk in the backseat and offered him a ride. He hesitated and said he was fine, that he was merely going across the street to the Fish Market (literally right across the street). I skeptically asked if he really thought he could cross the street. He got in the car, thanking me profusely. Three lane changes, two windy roads, 5 turns, and 2 conversations about suburban sprawl and the new construction on 31 later, we arrived at the Fish Market. He thanked me as if he owed me his life. And maybe he does, if he was really going to venture across 31 without a vehicle. ...But I think he probably would have just gone without lunch that day.
What is so deceptive about this photo is that it makes 31 look desolate. While you can't see any other cars here, the cars travel so rapidly that by the time a pedestrian was in the street, a car could whiz right by him or her. Along with the no sidewalk from my first picture, the depressing bore of the second picture, this third element of 6 lane highways seals the fate of any wanna-be pedestrian. The community deficit is suffering heavy amounts of traffic on a daily basis, the aggravation of seemingly simple tasks like going to a store across the street, and feeling pushed to be utilitarian about every daily task - getting in and out of the car and not being able to share just a few of the tasks with friends who happen to pass by (you would never know if they passed by anyway - they're in their cars).



Documenting Sprawl 2


This photo was taken on Greensprings Highway near Valley Avenue. It is an example of the suburban shopping center. It is all single-story, lacks housing, and has a big ol' parking lot in front of it that makes it unpleasant and difficult to walk to. I cannot tell you what it consists of, because I have never been compelled to walk around it. It looks the same as all the other shopping areas, one of which I actually have walked around. If this is the same one, it has a Vietnamese sandwich shop, an Arabic grocery store, a Korean restaurant, and probably a manicurist and a dollar store.
The L shape with no interesting shortcut connecting the two ends makes the walk along the entire building quite boring and seem to last forever. This discourages people from visiting all the shops or spending any more time in the area than necessary. When two people meet for lunch at one of the restaurants, they most likely have to drive there separately. When the meal is finished, they have nothing left to do except get back in their separate cars and drive their separate ways. Staying in the utilitarian shopping center with a giant parking lot and no interesting or safe walking paths nearby forces the people to escape the situation using their getaway cars.
The community benefit is being able to find a parking spot wherever anyone goes. The community deficit is decreased quality of life, making people more agitated at all the traffic they face every day with limited access to worthwhile exercise. What I mean, is that in order to exercise, people have to drive 30 minutes to a trail, go to a gym, or use whatever they have at home. They have to somehow motivate themselves to do any of those things, instead of simply getting their exercise naturally by walking to their shopping centers, going for a stroll with a friend after lunch, or at least walking past interesting buildings and people watching.

Documenting Sprawl in Birmingham, AL


I took this photo from the edge of someone's driveway in Bluff Park (Hoover). I think the house was deserted. I'm not surprised, given that the cars drive about 40-50mph right outside the driveway and I was pretty nervous backing out of the driveway, what with all the shrubbery blocking my view of the speedy cars. What I tried to focus on in this photo is the little shopping area just ahead. And the complete lack of any sidewalks to it. The far end of the street is covered in brush that would be very unpleasant to walk through, and this side of the street slopes down (so your right leg would be higher than your left leg as you're walking), has intermittent trees and bushes in the path, and zero protection from traffic.
This photo represents the depressingly complete lack of a street network. The reason I was even on this long, windy road was because they are doing construction on the collector road and the only way around is to drive through an extra 3 or 4 suburbs, lengthening my trip by 10-15 minutes. The streets are not narrow, traffic buffering, walkable, nor diverse, as a good neighborhood street should be. What could be a 7 minute walk to a nice little shopping area with restaurants immediately becomes an aggravating drive when you try backing out of the driveway into fast traffic. Or you fear for your life as you hobble along the sloped grass, hoping the drivers are paying attention and don't run you over.
This design strongly encourages driving, even to such a close location. It discourages neighbors from associating with each other, because the people are busy getting in or out of their cars to get to their next destination. There is no potential for bumping into your neighbor and walking to lunch together. It puts people in the frame of mind to just get to where they are going with the seriousness of driving a dangerous weapon amongst other dangerous vehicles that could just as easily crash into them. Neighbors don't usually want to be a nuisance, and when they see their neighbor out (which is almost always because they are getting in their car), they can only assume they are driving away to make it to a doctor's appointment and they have no time for chit-chat. In reality, they are getting in their cars for anything from work, to eating, to finding a suitable walking trail. Even if they invite the neighbor to have lunch with them, the neighbor would become a burden on the driver when the two were done eating and the driver wanted to go somewhere other than back home. Thus the neighbor is stuck grocery shopping with the driver. All in all, the lack of a sidewalk here makes all the neighbors seem busier and less approachable than if they could walk to their corner market, creating less sociability.